A Guide For Advertisers

Influencer fraud is the dark underbelly of the glittering world of social media stars. With the rise of influencer marketing, so too has risen the art of deception. From fake followers to phony engagements, some influencers have perfected the con, costing brands millions. So, how do you navigate this minefield without getting scammed? Buckle up, because we're diving into the murky waters of influencer fraud, spotlighting infamous cases, and giving you the tools to spot the fakes.

What is Influencer Fraud?

Influencer fraud is a sneaky form of digital marketing deception where influencers promote products or services without disclosing their true affiliations or using dishonest methods to inflate their popularity. This could be through fake accounts, bots, paid reviews, and more. The goal? To appear more influential than they actually are and to bag those lucrative brand deals.

Prime Examples of Influencer Fraud: 

The Artful Dodger: Anna Delvey

Remember Anna Delvey, the supposed German heiress who swindled New York’s elite? While not a traditional influencer, her story epitomizes the lengths some will go to create a fraudulent persona. She used social media to craft an image of opulence, duping everyone from hoteliers to bankers. This level of deceit isn’t too far removed from influencers who buy followers and engagement.

Fashion Faux Pas: Oobah Butler

Then there's Oobah Butler, the man who punked the fashion world by attending Paris Fashion Week posing as a fake fashion icon. He showcased how easy it is to build a believable yet entirely fraudulent presence. His stunt shone a spotlight on how appearance and perceived popularity can be entirely fabricated.

The Tinder Swindler

And who could forget the Tinder Swindler, who used Instagram to lure his victims by showcasing a lavish lifestyle. His fraudulent behavior wasn’t just about romance; it was about convincing people he was someone he wasn’t, using social media as his stage.

Why Does Influencer Fraud Happen?

The influencer market is booming, and with it, the competition. Influencers are a cheaper and more relatable alternative to celebrity endorsements, making them attractive to brands. However, this allure also attracts fraudsters looking to make a quick buck by faking their way to fame. Influencers hold a certain level of credibility; people trust them more than traditional ads. But that trust can be easily manipulated.

How to Avoid Influencer Fraud

So, how can you avoid falling into the influencer fraud trap? Here are some tips to keep your brand safe:

1. Check Their Overall Online Presence

Start by scrutinizing their social media accounts, then use a wider internet search to ensure there is nothing problematic. A significant follower count is a good start, but dig deeper. Look at the engagement on their posts. Are their followers liking, commenting, and sharing their content? Or does it look suspiciously quiet for someone with a million followers?

2. Scrutinize the Comments

Pay attention to the comments on their posts. Genuine engagement is key. If you see lots of generic comments or an influencer who never responds, this might indicate bot activity.

3. Analyze Engagement Rates

Engagement rates are more telling than follower counts. An influencer with a high follower count but low engagement might have bought their followers. Look for those who have high engagement relative to their follower count.

4. Request a Portfolio

Ask for a portfolio of previous work. Examine it closely for any red flags. Are there inconsistencies or signs of amateurism? A thorough check can save you from potential headaches.

5. Evaluate Their Credibility

Check if they have a high follower-to-following ratio. A balanced ratio usually indicates genuine engagement. If most of their followers don’t interact with their content, that’s a red flag.

6. Verify Audience Insights

Don’t shy away from asking for audience insights. A legitimate influencer will have no problem sharing their demographics, engagement metrics, and past campaign results.

Conclusion

Influencer fraud can cost your brand not just money, but credibility. By being vigilant and following these tips, you can avoid being duped by fraudulent influencers. Remember, it’s okay to ask for audience insights and dig deeper into an influencer’s background. After all, in the world of influencer marketing, it’s better to be safe than sorry. Keep your brand safe, your wallet intact, and your marketing campaigns fraud-free. Cheers to savvy advertising!

‍